Cigar Lighters – Traditional Matches vs. Modern Methods

Lighting a cigar is not just a preparatory step; it’s an art, a prelude to the enjoyment that follows. Just as aficionados debate over the best types of cigars, the method of lighting those cigars often stirs passionate conversations. At the heart of this discussion is the age-old debate between the charm of traditional wooden matches and the precision of modern lighters. Each method has its proponents and its unique benefits. This article seeks to explore the allure of both, allowing readers to appreciate the nuances of each approach and perhaps even reevaluate their own lighting ritual. Whether you’re a novice looking to delve into the world of cigars or a seasoned enthusiast, understanding the nuances of these lighting methods can significantly elevate your smoking experience.

The Allure of Traditional Wooden Matches:

1. The Ritualistic Experience: Using wooden matches harkens back to a bygone era, adding an air of sophistication and ritual to the cigar lighting process. Many aficionados swear by this method, finding solace in the patience required to strike, let the sulfur burn off, and then toast the foot of the cigar.

2. Purity of Flavor: Matches, when allowed to burn past their initial ignition chemicals, offer a clean flame. This purity ensures that no extraneous tastes or aromas interfere with the cigar’s flavor profile, allowing for a true experience of the tobacco blend.

3. Gradual Toasting: The soft flame of a wooden match offers a gentle heat, ideal for toasting the foot of the cigar. This slow toasting ensures an even burn and allows for the flavors to develop gradually, enhancing the initial puffs.

4. Nostalgia and Aesthetics: There’s an undeniable charm in using matches, reminiscent of old cigar lounges and classic movies. It’s a more deliberate method, one that adds a touch of elegance and nostalgia to the smoking session.

5. Environmentally Friendly: Wooden matches, being biodegradable, present a more eco-friendly option. For those conscious about their environmental footprint, this method might appeal more than disposable plastic lighters.

While wooden matches offer an array of benefits, they aren’t without their challenges. They’re susceptible to wind and moisture, require a steady hand and patience, and might not be the most practical choice for every occasion. Still, their charm and the unique experience they provide make them a favorite among many cigar enthusiasts.

Modern Lighting Tools: The Convenience and Precision

1. Butane (Bic-type) Lighters: Butane lighters are the most popular choice among modern cigar smokers. They offer a clean, odorless flame that doesn’t impact the taste of the cigar. Their consistency, ability to function well in windy conditions, and ease of use make them a staple in many cigar enthusiasts’ collections.

2. Torch Lighters: A subset of butane lighters, torch lighters produce a powerful and concentrated blue flame. This intensity allows for quick and even lighting, especially beneficial for larger ring gauge cigars. The pinpoint accuracy of the torch flame ensures an even burn from the start.

3. Electric Lighters: A newer addition to the cigar world, electric or “plasma” lighters use a battery-powered electrical arc to ignite the cigar. They’re windproof, rechargeable, and don’t require any fuel, making them a convenient and eco-friendly option.

4. Benefits of Modern Methods:

  • Speed: Modern lighters, especially torches, light cigars faster than matches.
  • Practicality: They work well in various environments, from windy golf courses to rainy camping trips.
  • Consistency: Modern lighters offer a consistent flame, ensuring an even light every time.
  • Safety: Features like lock mechanisms and flame adjusters offer a safer lighting experience.

5. The Trade-offs: While modern methods offer undeniable advantages, they can sometimes impact the cigar’s taste, especially if the flame is held too close or if the lighter isn’t maintained properly. There’s also the matter of refilling or recharging, which requires additional accessories or equipment.

The convenience and precision of modern lighting tools have undoubtedly made them a preferred choice for many. Yet, it’s essential to understand their nuances and ensure they’re used correctly to preserve the cigar’s integrity and flavor.

Comparison: Matches vs. Modern Lighters

1. Flame Temperature and Its Impact on the Cigar: One of the most significant differences between matches and modern lighters lies in the temperature of the flame they produce. Wooden matches, especially those made from cedar, tend to burn at a cooler temperature. This gentler flame can prevent the tobacco from getting scorched, preserving its inherent flavors and preventing any bitter aftertaste. In contrast, torch lighters produce an intensely hot flame, ensuring quick and even lighting but run the risk of overheating the tobacco if not used correctly. One benefit torch lighters do have over matches is the ability to easily correct a cigar if it has an issue, especially with a single flame torch like the Hiland’s Palio Torch Lighter. This lighter has a laser-like flame that can not only light a cigar evenly, but also correct issues should they arise.

2. Convenience and Portability: Modern lighters, particularly butane lighters, are designed for convenience. They offer a more prolonged flame, are wind-resistant, and can be easily refilled or recharged. This makes them particularly suited for outdoor settings or for those who smoke cigars frequently. On the other hand, wooden matches might require multiple attempts, especially in windy conditions, and can be a bit cumbersome to carry around, especially if you need to bring along a sizable number for prolonged smoking sessions.

3. Cost-effectiveness and Longevity: While a good quality butane lighter can be a bit of an investment upfront, its longevity and refill capability can make it cost-effective in the long run. Matches, being disposable, might seem cheaper, but if you’re lighting cigars regularly, you’ll find yourself going through boxes fairly quickly. Additionally, high-quality cedar matches can come at a premium price.

4. Environmental Considerations: When it comes to the environment, matches have an edge. They are biodegradable and leave behind minimal waste. In contrast, disposable lighters contribute significantly to global plastic waste, ending up in landfills. Even refillable lighters, though less wasteful, involve the production and disposal of butane canisters. That said, the manufacturing process for matches, especially on an industrial scale, does have its environmental impact, primarily if sourced from non-sustainable wood.

In sum, while modern lighters offer undeniable convenience and efficiency, wooden matches bring a sense of charm, ritual, and environmental consciousness to the cigar-lighting experience. Choosing between them often boils down to personal preference, occasion, and one’s dedication to the ritual of cigar smoking.

Considerations When Choosing a Lighting Method:

1. Occasion: Relaxed Evening at Home: For many aficionados, the act of smoking a cigar is as much about the ritual as it is about the flavors of the tobacco. In a quiet, controlled setting like a relaxed evening at home, using traditional matches can add a touch of elegance and nostalgia to the experience. The slow burn and the scent of the cedar can enhance the anticipation and the appreciation of the cigar.

Outdoor Events: When you’re outside, possibly in windy conditions or when you’re on the move, convenience takes precedence. This is where modern lighters, especially torch lighters, come into their own. They offer a quick, efficient, and consistent flame that isn’t easily blown out, making them ideal for events like barbecues, golf outings, or beach parties.

2. Personal Preferences: Ritual vs. Convenience: Every cigar smoker is unique, and what works for one might not work for another. Some deeply cherish the ritualistic aspect of lighting up a cigar, taking their time, and savoring every moment, for which matches are often preferred. On the other hand, some prioritize efficiency and consistency, especially if they smoke cigars frequently, making modern lighters a more appealing choice.

3. Budget Considerations: Your budget can play a crucial role in deciding between matches and modern lighters. And, while you’re watching your wallet, you can check out our cigar clearance and specials! While matches might seem cheaper at first glance, especially if you’re not a regular smoker, their costs can add up over time, especially if you opt for high-quality cedar matches. On the other hand, a good quality butane or torch lighter might have a higher upfront cost, but its longevity and refill capabilities can make it a more cost-effective choice in the long run.

In the end, your lighting method should enhance your cigar smoking experience, not detract from it. Whether you opt for the charm of wooden matches or the efficiency of a modern lighter, the key is to choose a method that aligns with your preferences and the situation at hand.

The journey of lighting a cigar is as varied and personal as the choice of the cigar itself. While the charm of traditional matches, with their rich history and sense of ritual, can elevate the experience, the efficiency and precision of modern lighters cannot be understated. Each method has its merits, and the choice ultimately boils down to individual preferences, occasion, and budget. At Hiland’s Cigars, we understand the nuances that make your cigar experience personal and unique. Whether you’re a purist who enjoys the age-old tradition of using matches or someone who leans towards the convenience of modern methods, we have a range of cigar lighters tailored to suit your needs. Great a great deal on your cigars and pick up a lighter today!

Get an Awesome Cigar Lighter

FAQ: Lighting Cigars – Matches vs. Lighters

  1. Is it better to light a cigar with a lighter or a match?
    • Both methods have their merits. While matches provide a more traditional and ritualistic approach to lighting, lighters, especially torch lighters, offer a consistent and even heat that can make the lighting process quicker and more efficient.
  2. Are matches the best for cigars?
    • Many cigar aficionados believe that wooden matches, particularly cedar matches, offer a pure flame that doesn’t introduce any foreign flavors to the cigar. However, it’s essential to let the sulfur burn off before lighting the cigar.
  3. Should you use a lighter for a cigar?
    • Yes, many cigar smokers prefer butane torch lighters for their efficiency and ability to provide a consistent, high-temperature flame, which is especially useful in windy conditions or for touch-ups.
  4. Why do people light cigars with matches?
    • Lighting cigars with matches is often seen as a traditional and ceremonial act. The slower burn and the act of striking the match can add to the overall experience and ritual of enjoying a cigar. Additionally, cedar matches can add a pleasant aroma during the lighting process.
  5. Are Bic lighters OK for cigars?
    • While Bic lighters can light a cigar, they are not the preferred choice for many enthusiasts. The fluid used in these lighters can impart an unwanted flavor to the cigar. Butane torch lighters or matches are often recommended for a purer lighting experience.
  6. What kind of lighter is best for cigars?
    • Butane torch lighters are widely considered the best for cigars. They offer a strong, consistent flame that lights the cigar evenly and quickly, without introducing any foreign flavors.
To top